Exceptionalism
One of the ideas that floored me back in ninth grade was the idea that Europe might not be a contintent. After all, I grew up with seven continents. But the argument goes as follows: there is no reason why Europe should be a continent. It's on the same continental plate as the rest of Asia, there are no geographic features to differentiate it from the rest of asia, and in terms of terrain, it blends in to the Asian steppes pretty well..or at least just as well as all the other parts of Asia. The reason why Europe gets to be a continent is that it was European who drew the maps way back when, and they felt the need to have their own place. Somehow living in just another part of Asia (or Eurasia as my history teacher used to call it) isn't as good as having a continent of your own. Basically its a case of exceptionalism: the Europeans wanted to be sepparate from the Asian peoples, so they made Europe its own continent.
Well, here another idea. What are you? You're a living organism made up of other living organisms: cells. Those cells are made up of organelles. Now, cells are alive but organelles aren't. Why is that? There is no reason why there should be a difference except that we have decided that it is so. Placing the barrier between life and non-life between cells and organelles keeps it well away from us. After all, if it weren't there, organelles could be alive....or cells could be not alive, and if a cells could not be living then you could too, right? It sounds crazy, but think about it. What are organelles but a series of chemical compunds linked together. What are cells but a series of organelles linked together...meaning that in the end a cell is a much larger group of compunds. What are you but a group of cells tied together, and thus a reeeeaaallly large group of compunds. Maybe we put the boundary there to sepparate ourelves from non-life in the same way that the Europeans made Europe its own continent in order to make themselves sepparate. In reality, maybe there isn't much of a difference at all.
I'm not saying that there's no such thing as life...just that this is a kind of wacky idea that I think people should think about--if for no othere reason, then because it gives you a headache. And we all need that kind of headache every once in a while.
1 Comments:
Well, actually, Europe DOES lie on its own tectonic plate, separate from Asia (the split occurs at India). However, if we were going by tectonic plates to distinguish continents, we'd have a lot more than seven.
I always forgot about Antarctica being a continent. It's just too far south. So I never got them all right as a kid. It made me bitter towards the whole "continent" deal.
Organelles aren't alive because they do not have their own DNA, nucleus, or "brain" center. The cells that compose them are because they contain these things. Remember, the key to life is reproduction: organelles cannot reproduce; cells can. They fall in that "grey" area, like viruses almost. (But not quite - viruses DO have their own DNA/RNA and DO replicate...and yet are not alive...). Nothing is ever certain, nothing ever black and white; there is always a grey area.
So, in essence, you can be semi-alive.
-your dorky girlfriend
Post a Comment
<< Home